Orders from Moscow?

One of the abiding Cold War myths was that Stalin, or perhaps the Russian Communist Party directed the world-wide revolutionary movement through the Comintern. I hear it even today from old Trots, who suggest that one group or another used to follow Stalin’s orders. It was a question Stalin himself was asked by delegates from the USA in 1927.

The assertion that the American Communists work under “orders from Moscow” is absolutely false. No Communist in the world would agree to work “under orders” from outside against his own convictions, against his will, and contrary to the requirements of the situation. And even if there were such Communists they would not be worth a farthing.

The Communists are the boldest and bravest of people, and they are fighting a host of enemies. The merit of the Communists is, among other things, that they are able to stand up for their convictions. It is, therefore, strange to speak of American Communists as having no convictions of their own and capable only of working “under orders” from outside …

Some people think that the members of the Communist International in Moscow do nothing but sit and write instructions to all countries. More than sixty countries are affiliated to the Comintern, so you can picture to yourselves the position of the members of the Comintern, who neither sleep nor eat, but sit day and night writing instructions to all those countries. (Laughter.) (Works, volume 10, pp. 134-35).

Come to think of it, Marx and Engels and the First International were widely accused of ‘master-minding’ the Paris commune in 1871.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Orders from Moscow?

  1. Of course not many jailers are needed in a dictatorial angst ridden systems. But from many many (auto)biographies and (sometimes proud) testimonials it is completely clear that the CPs were ruled from Moscow. Just think about the total disorientation during the Molotov-Rippen pact period.
    Or in your own world: One pope only has a few cardinals and they a few bishops to ultimately dictate the life of many millions.
    Joost

    1. Joost, you may well be correct and I am happy to agree.

      But you would need to show how the accusation was different to the widespread one that Marx and the First International directed the Paris Commune (he deals with it in the famous interview with the New York World – http://marx.eserver.org/1871-interview.world.txt.

      Or indeed that Negri masterminded the attacks of the Red Brigades in the 1970s.

      The analogy with the Roman Catholic Church may not work so well, for many Roman Catholics simply disagree with and disobey the bishop of Rome and his underlings.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.