On the completion of reading Stalin

I have at last completed my careful reading of the published works of Ioseb Besarionis dze Jughashvili (Stalin). On the way, I have found that few actually do so, for the attitudes to Stalin seem to be set. This is especially so among the many on the Left, for whom Stalin is the great betrayer. The assumption is that he was not a socialist at all, so one may conveniently neglect any serious engagement. The problem is that one simply misses the rich history of socialism in power, with all of its mistakes and achievements.

I have also found that the name ‘Stalin’ generates a profound polarisation, between veneration or demonisation. The latter is usually the case, whether one is engaging with the closed circles of thought in European Marxism, liberals who seek to find yet more reasons to condemn Stalin while engaging in ‘objective’ research’ and even in China, where one would expect a somewhat different approach and interest given the long Chinese experience of socialism in power. On my part, I am more interested in the dynamics of such polarisation rather than falling into its trap.

Perhaps the most intriguing aspect of reading Stalin and posting items from his works is the way preset assumptions concerning Stalin influence how my own perspective is understood. Simply because I have been intrigued by his works and posted quotations that reveal unexpected dimensions of his thought, some have assumed that I am a ‘Stalinist’, whatever that means. (Stalin himself merely identified as a Marxist-Leninist.)

Above all, my interest in Stalin emerged as I became increasingly drawn to understanding the experiences of socialism in power. This began when I was studying Lenin and I found the time after the October Revolution the most significant. Lenin was the first who was able to say – from direct experience – that working towards a revolution and achieving power was the easy part. Far, far more complex and fraught with problems was the exercise of power. Stalin too found this a reality, and Mao soon found that Lenin’s observation was correct. The strange thing is that many on the Left avoid dealing with this topic. This is a profound shame, since there is a wealth of experience from which to learn.

Advertisements

17 thoughts on “On the completion of reading Stalin

  1. The attitude towards Stalin is very slowly changing. I see that in my old left wing friends and there are many websites and FB sites dedicated to Stalin.

  2. Tis very hard to look at Stalin without being perplexed by the scale of violence that happened to Russians on his watch. Also their is the matter of his positions on ‘socialism in one country,’ his handling of the Comintern-cominform, the Spanish Civil war once in charge of the Soviet union. Stuff he gets bashed on frequently from the left.On the whole I’m very curious about what the man himself had to say re: these issues.

  3. Not many people read Stalin these days, so it is a real achievement on your part. Still, as I’ve noticed, Stalin didn’t always followed his words to the letter (to put it mildly), so to really know Stalin it is important to know his deeds. For example, he never admitted that he ordered to kill Trotsky.

    1. This is the usual reason why people do not read Stalin: the assumption of hypocrisy and suspicion of what he wrote. I think we need to get past that assumption, since it hobbles proper research. He always saw himself as true Marxist and acted on his beliefs, however we may wish to assess them.

  4. As someone who has long admired Stalin, and currently through reading his CWs to Vol 10 at this stage, I have enjoyed the excerpts you’ve posted and your comments on them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.